Section I · The Ranked Twelve
From best to twelfth.
Sorted by what each area does well at its price point. The number-one pick is the one we would book first given a free pick from all twelve.
No. I
The Port Royal Gulf-front estate, six-bedroom.
Typical: 6 BR, sleeps 12. Area: Port Royal. Peak rate: $70,000 to $120,000 / week. Usually included: housekeeping, pool and dock maintenance, landscaping. Usually not: chef, daily housekeeping, driver.
Why it ranks here: Port Royal is the trophy address in Naples, the gated-by-prestige enclave between the Gulf and Naples Bay, and a Gulf-front estate here is the thing the rate is for: private beach frontage, deep-water dock access to the Gulf, and a short drive to Third Street South. It clears every other area for a trophy week because nothing else in Naples combines beach, boat, and the Port Royal address.
What we would change: the rate only works at full occupancy and only if the Gulf front is the point. A group that wants golf and security over beach should drop to Grey Oaks at No. VII for half the rate.
Get the free villa buyer’s guide
No. II
The Aqualane Shores waterfront five-bedroom.
Typical: 5 BR, sleeps 10. Area: Aqualane Shores. Peak rate: $34,000 to $62,000 / week. Usually included: housekeeping, pool and dock maintenance. Usually not: chef, driver, private beach.
Why it ranks here: Aqualane Shores sits just south of Old Naples, a grid of canal-front homes with deep-water docks and a short walk to Third Street South. For a boating family it is the value answer to Port Royal: the same Gulf access by water and the same walk to the restaurants, without the private beach frontage that drives Port Royal’s rate.
What we would change: these are canal-front, not beachfront. The beach is a short drive or a longer walk. Confirm the dock depth and the bridge clearance if you are bringing or chartering a larger boat.
Get the free villa buyer’s guide
No. III
The Old Naples beach-block five-bedroom.
Typical: 5 BR, sleeps 10. Area: Old Naples. Peak rate: $30,000 to $58,000 / week. Usually included: housekeeping, pool maintenance. Usually not: chef, dock, driver.
Why it ranks here: Old Naples is the walkable historic core, and a home in the blocks near the beach and Fifth Avenue South is the most location-rich pick on the list. Walk to the pier, the beach, and the best restaurants and shopping in the city without a car. The right pick for a group that wants the town as much as the water.
What we would change: the closer to Fifth Avenue, the more foot traffic and the less privacy. For a quiet beach week, the blocks south toward Gordon Drive trade walkability for calm.
Get the free villa buyer’s guide
No. IV
The Coquina Sands four-bedroom.
Typical: 4 BR, sleeps 8. Area: Coquina Sands. Peak rate: $24,000 to $44,000 / week. Usually included: housekeeping, pool maintenance. Usually not: chef, dock, driver.
Why it ranks here: Coquina Sands sits just north of Old Naples between the Gulf and the bay, quieter and more residential than the core, with Lowdermilk Park beach and the Naples Beach Club golf within reach. A four-bedroom here is the smaller-group answer to Old Naples: the same coast, a calmer street, walkable to a beach park.
What we would change: fewer homes come to the rental market here than in Old Naples, so the inventory is thin. Book early for the February and March weeks.
Get the free villa buyer’s guide
No. V
The Moorings waterfront five-bedroom.
Typical: 5 BR, sleeps 10. Area: The Moorings. Peak rate: $26,000 to $48,000 / week. Usually included: housekeeping, pool and dock maintenance. Usually not: chef, driver.
Why it ranks here: the Moorings is the established waterfront neighborhood north of Coquina Sands, with Gulf-access canals, a private resident beach, and a calm family pace. A waterfront five-bedroom here gives a boating family the dock and the beach access at a rate below the Old Naples core, with more space per dollar.
What we would change: the resident beach access varies by home and by HOA rules. Confirm in writing exactly what beach access the specific rental carries before booking.
Get the free villa buyer’s guide
No. VI
The Park Shore Gulf-access six-bedroom.
Typical: 6 BR, sleeps 12. Area: Park Shore. Peak rate: $28,000 to $52,000 / week. Usually included: housekeeping, pool and dock maintenance. Usually not: chef, driver, private beach.
Why it ranks here: Park Shore runs along Venetian Bay north of the Moorings, with Gulf-access canals, the Venetian Village shops and restaurants on the water, and a private beach park for residents. A six-bedroom here suits a larger group that wants the boat, the bay, and the walkable Venetian Village without the Old Naples rate.
What we would change: much of Park Shore’s beachfront is high-rise condo, not single-family. The villas are bay-side; the Gulf beach is the resident park, a short drive or walk.
Get the free villa buyer’s guide
No. VII
The Grey Oaks golf-estate six-bedroom.
Typical: 6 BR, sleeps 12. Area: Grey Oaks. Peak rate: $22,000 to $40,000 / week. Usually included: housekeeping, pool maintenance, gated security, club access (where transferable). Usually not: chef, beachfront, driver.
Why it ranks here: Grey Oaks is the central gated golf community, three courses and a serious clubhouse a few miles inland, and the answer for a golf group or a family that wants gated security and space over beach. A six-bedroom estate here sleeps twelve with room to spread, at a rate well below the Gulf-access homes.
What we would change: it is not on the beach, and the club access on a rental depends on the owner’s membership transfer rules. Confirm exactly what golf and clubhouse access the rental carries.
Get the free villa buyer’s guide
No. VIII
The Pelican Bay high-rise-adjacent four-bedroom.
Typical: 4 BR, sleeps 8. Area: Pelican Bay. Peak rate: $20,000 to $36,000 / week. Usually included: housekeeping, pool maintenance, Pelican Bay beach-tram and amenity access. Usually not: chef, driver, beachfront.
Why it ranks here: Pelican Bay is the large amenity community north of Park Shore, best known for its private beach access via tram through a mangrove preserve and its two beachfront restaurants. A single-family four-bedroom here is the pick for a group that wants the amenity bundle, the tennis, and the beach tram without buying beachfront.
What we would change: Pelican Bay is mostly high-rise condo. Single-family rentals are limited and the amenity access rules vary; confirm the beach-tram and restaurant access for the specific home.
Get the free villa buyer’s guide
No. IX
The Marco Island beachfront five-bedroom.
Typical: 5 BR, sleeps 10. Area: Marco Island. Peak rate: $20,000 to $42,000 / week. Usually included: housekeeping, pool and dock maintenance. Usually not: chef, driver.
Why it ranks here: Marco Island is the barrier island about 30 minutes south of Naples, with wide Gulf beaches, deep-water canals, and a more relaxed, family-resort pace. A beachfront or canal-front five-bedroom here gives a family the Gulf beach and the boat at a rate below comparable Naples-proper waterfront, with the trade of distance from the Old Naples scene.
What we would change: Marco is a 30-minute drive from the Naples restaurants and shopping. For a group whose week centers on Fifth Avenue and Third Street, the island is the wrong base.
Get the free villa buyer’s guide
No. X
The Vineyards gated four-bedroom.
Typical: 4 BR, sleeps 8. Area: The Vineyards. Peak rate: $18,000 to $32,000 / week. Usually included: housekeeping, pool maintenance, gated security. Usually not: chef, beachfront, driver.
Why it ranks here: the Vineyards is a large gated golf community east of the city, the value end of the gated market, with two courses and family amenities at the lowest entry rate on this list. The pick for a golf-and-pool week where the beach is a 15-minute drive and the budget goes to the course, not the coast.
What we would change: it is well inland, and the beach drive in season traffic can run 20 to 30 minutes. Right for golf, wrong if daily beach time is the point.
Get the free villa buyer’s guide
No. XI
The Quail West estate seven-bedroom.
Typical: 7 BR, sleeps 14. Area: Quail West. Peak rate: $26,000 to $46,000 / week. Usually included: housekeeping, pool maintenance, gated security, club access (where transferable). Usually not: chef, beachfront, driver.
Why it ranks here: Quail West, straddling the Naples-Bonita Springs line, is the big-estate gated community for a large group that wants acreage, two championship courses, and a substantial house over a beach. A seven-bedroom here sleeps fourteen with room to spread, at a rate the beachfront homes cannot match for the bedroom count.
What we would change: it is the farthest from the Gulf on this list, roughly 25 to 35 minutes to the beach. This is a villa for a group that wants the property and the golf to be the destination.
Get the free villa buyer’s guide
No. XII
The Bonita Bay golf-and-marina five-bedroom.
Typical: 5 BR, sleeps 10. Area: Bonita Bay, Bonita Springs. Peak rate: $20,000 to $38,000 / week. Usually included: housekeeping, pool maintenance, gated security, marina and amenity access (where transferable). Usually not: chef, beachfront, driver.
Why it ranks here: Bonita Bay sits at the northern edge of the Naples market near the RSW airport, a large gated community with five courses, a marina on the Imperial River, and a private beach park reached by shuttle. A five-bedroom here suits a group splitting time between golf, boating, and a short airport run, at a rate below Naples proper.
What we would change: it is the northernmost pick, closer to Fort Myers than to Old Naples, so the Naples scene is a 25-minute drive. The beach park access is by shuttle and varies by membership; confirm it.
Get the free villa buyer’s guide