A four-bedroom a short walk from Edgartown harbor asks about $42,000 a week in August and closer to $20,000 in the third week of June, for the same house and the same light. The Vineyard prices high summer above everything, the supply of large waterfront houses is small, and the car ferry from Woods Hole is the one logistics line that catches most first-time renters. The full structure, by town and season, with three worked examples.
This site is editorially independent. We earn no affiliate commission and accept no payment to influence our rankings. More on our how-we-make-money page.
The number that matters first: $12,000 to $225,000 per week. That is the real spread for villa rentals on Martha’s Vineyard, and where you land inside it turns on four things, in this order: the week of the year, whether the house is up-Island or down-Island, whether it touches the water, and the number of bedrooms. The Island runs on a short, fierce summer, and the stock of large waterfront houses that trade as rentals is genuinely small, which holds the top of the market firm regardless of the wider economy.
The calendar has one clear apex. Mid-July through the end of August is the busiest and dearest stretch, with the single dearest weeks falling around the Agricultural Fair in late August. Summer runs two to three times the spring figure. The shoulder of late May, June, September, and early October holds warm water and open kitchens at 30 to 45 percent under the peak, and the off-season from November to April sits far lower with much of the Island shut.
Indicative weekly rates in US dollars for staffed or self-catered villas across the Island. Off-season is roughly November to April. Shoulder is late May, June, September, and early October. Summer peak is mid-July through August, the apex column, quoted as a weekly rate. Waterfront and up-Island estates sit at the top of each band.
| Villa size | Off-season (Nov–Apr) | Shoulder (Jun, Sep) | Summer peak (Jul–Aug) |
|---|---|---|---|
| 3 bedrooms | $7,000 to $12,000 | $12,000 to $22,000 | $24,000 to $38,000 |
| 4 bedrooms | $10,000 to $17,000 | $18,000 to $32,000 | $34,000 to $58,000 |
| 5 bedrooms | $16,000 to $28,000 | $30,000 to $52,000 | $55,000 to $98,000 |
| 6+ waterfront | $28,000 to $55,000 | $50,000 to $95,000 | $98,000 to $225,000+ |
Bands reflect houses across Edgartown, Oak Bluffs, Vineyard Haven, Chilmark, and Aquinnah, May 2026. Up-Island waterfront with private beach rights sits at the top of each band.
The Vineyard splits into six towns that price very differently. Down-Island, you pay for walkability. Edgartown, with its white captains’ houses and the harbor full of yawls, is the trophy town, and a house within walking distance of Main Street and the Chappy ferry asks a clear premium. Oak Bluffs, livelier and younger, with the gingerbread cottages and the Inkwell, runs a little softer. Vineyard Haven, where the ferries land, is the practical down-Island pick and the easiest arrival.
Up-Island is the other market. Chilmark, taking in Menemsha and the long south-shore beaches, holds the largest private estates, the ones on acreage with water frontage and a deeded path to the sand. Aquinnah, out by the Gay Head cliffs, is the most remote and the most exclusive, with the fewest rentals of all. West Tisbury sits in between, rural and quieter. Up-Island you trade the walk to town for privacy, land, and a car you will use every day.
Massachusetts charges a 5.7 percent state room occupancy excise on any rental under 31 nights. On top of that, most Vineyard towns have adopted a local-option excise of 4 to 6 percent, so plan on roughly 10 to 12 percent in total. On a $42,000 August week that is about $4,600 to $5,000. Unlike Cape Cod and Nantucket, the Vineyard sits outside the Cape Cod and Islands Water Protection Fund unless a town votes to opt in, so the 2.75 percent fund surcharge generally does not land here.
One line catches professionally managed houses. A town may charge a community impact fee of up to 3 percent on short-term rentals where an operator runs more than one property locally. Owner-managed houses usually avoid it, but a villa booked through a large management company can carry it, so ask whether the quoted rate includes that line before you sign.
Most Vineyard houses let self-catered with an end-of-stay clean of $600 to $1,500 depending on size. A private chef, the upgrade most families want for a summer week, runs $500 to $850 per day plus food and books up fast in July and August. Expect a refundable security deposit of $3,000 to $20,000 by card hold, returned within two weeks of checkout.
Each budget is built from the rate plus the fees that land on the invoice. The roughly 11 percent excise, the chef, and the car-ferry reservation are the lines that move the Vineyard total most.
Headline: $20,000 / wk (third week of June, self-catered).
Excise (11%) $2,200. Cleaning fee $700. Provisioning and a car reservation $1,100.
All-in: about $24,000 for the week, roughly $3,430 a night for a house that sleeps six.
Headline: $42,000 / wk (mid-August, walk to Main Street).
Excise (11%) $4,620. Cleaning fee $1,000. Chef three dinners $2,100 plus food $1,100.
All-in: about $50,820 for the week, roughly $7,260 a night for eight.
Headline: $120,000 / wk (up-Island, private beach path).
Excise (11%) $13,200. Cleaning fee $1,800. Chef for the week $4,500 plus food $2,800.
All-in: about $142,300 before gratuities and a second car.
Three levers move the all-in cost on a Vineyard week, and one of them is purely about timing the ferry.
Take the post-Labor-Day shoulder over August. The water is at its warmest in mid-September, the restaurants are still open, the crowds thin out, and rates fall 30 to 45 percent off the August peak. Unless your dates are locked to school holidays, the second week of September is the better week and the larger saving on the Island.
Trade up-Island acreage for a down-Island walk. The Chilmark waterfront estate is the one everyone pictures, and it costs far more than a comparable house a short walk from Edgartown or Oak Bluffs, where you can leave the car parked all week. If your days run on the harbor and in town anyway, the down-Island house puts the saving toward the chef.
Book the car ferry the day your dates are firm. The thing we would change about most first Vineyard trips is the scramble for a Steamship Authority car slot in July, which sells out months ahead. Reserve it the moment the villa is confirmed, or plan to arrive on a passenger fast ferry and hire a car on-Island, which removes the single most common Vineyard headache.
The Vineyard is reached by sea or by a short flight. The Steamship Authority runs the only car ferry, a 45-minute crossing from Woods Hole, and its summer vehicle reservations are the tightest logistics line on the Island. Passenger-only fast ferries run from Hyannis, New Bedford, and Falmouth and need no car slot. Martha’s Vineyard Airport at the centre of the Island takes private aircraft and seasonal scheduled service, and a charter from New York or Boston puts you on the ground in well under an hour.
The season to watch is hurricane season, which runs along the New England coast from roughly August into October. A direct hit is rare, but the tail of a tropical system or an autumn nor’easter can cancel ferries for a day and reshuffle an arrival, so build a buffer into travel either side of a stay in that window. Summer itself is reliable, with warm days, cool nights, and water that peaks in temperature in late August and September.
From about $12,000 per week for a three-bedroom in the spring shoulder to $225,000 or more for a large up-Island waterfront estate in August. Most quality four to five-bedrooms land between $34,000 and $95,000 per week over the July and August peak.
Mid-July to the end of August, with the dearest weeks around the Agricultural Fair in late August. Summer rates run roughly two to three times the spring shoulder, the best houses book six to nine months ahead, and most carry a Saturday-to-Saturday week minimum.
Massachusetts charges a 5.7 percent state room occupancy excise on stays under 31 days, and most Vineyard towns add a local-option excise of 4 to 6 percent, so budget roughly 10 to 12 percent in total. The Vineyard sits outside the Cape Cod and Islands Water Protection Fund unless a town opts in, so the 2.75 percent fund surcharge generally does not apply. Professionally managed listings can carry a community impact fee of up to 3 percent.
For a car, yes. The Steamship Authority runs the only car ferry, from Woods Hole, and summer vehicle slots sell out months ahead. Book it the moment your villa dates are firm. Passenger fast ferries from Hyannis, New Bedford, and Falmouth need no car slot, so many renters arrive on foot and hire a car on-Island.
Waterfront up-Island, in Chilmark and Aquinnah, holds the highest rates because the lots are large and rarely traded. Down-Island, in Edgartown, Oak Bluffs, and Vineyard Haven, you pay for walkability to the harbor and town rather than acreage. A harbor-view house in Edgartown and a Chilmark waterfront estate can ask the same number for very different stays.
November to April runs well below half the August figure, though much of the Island quiets down. Late September and early October, after Labor Day, hold the best value with warm water, open restaurants, and rates 30 to 45 percent under the summer peak.
Our quarterly briefing covers Vineyard villa rates, the best-value weeks across the seasons, and which towns earn their premium. No spam, unsubscribe anytime.
When an Island inn beats a rental on the math. The restaurants worth a summer booking. The bars worth the late ferry.