Section I · The Ranked Twelve
From best to twelfth.
Sorted by what each pocket does well at its price point. The number-one pick is the one we would book first given a free pick from all twelve.
No. I
The Rhinebeck and river estates villa, six-bedroom.
Typical: 6 BR, sleeps 12. Pocket: Rhinebeck and the east-bank estates, Dutchess. Peak rate: $22,000 to $40,000 / week. Usually included: housekeeping, pool maintenance, grounds. Usually not: chef, daily staff.
Why it ranks here: Rhinebeck is the prettiest and most walkable village on the river, and the estate belt around it holds the grand houses on acreage near the old Astor and Mills properties, with the best restaurants and shops in the valley a short drive. It clears the rest because no other pocket pairs the village, the estate quality, and the river setting at this level.
What we would change: Rhinebeck weekends in foliage season book far ahead and the village fills, so the appeal is the estate and the access rather than seclusion. Take a house out on the estate roads for the quiet, with the village a few minutes off.
Get the free villa buyer’s guide
No. II
The Millbrook horse-country estate, six-bedroom.
Typical: 6 BR, sleeps 12. Pocket: Millbrook, the Dutchess hunt country. Peak rate: $20,000 to $38,000 / week. Usually included: housekeeping, pool, grounds. Usually not: chef, the village on foot.
Why it ranks here: Millbrook is the old-money horse country east of the river, rolling estates, the Millbrook hunt, vineyards, and the Innisfree and Wing's Castle gardens, the pocket with the most land and the deepest privacy, the pick for a group that wants the country-estate version over the river town. A six-bedroom here is the pick for acreage and quiet.
What we would change: Millbrook is inland and spread out, so the river and its towns are a 20-minute drive and a car is essential. Book it for the estates and the privacy, with the river and the restaurants a short run west.
Get the free villa buyer’s guide
No. III
The Hudson and Columbia County villa, five-bedroom.
Typical: 5 BR, sleeps 10. Pocket: Hudson and Columbia County. Peak rate: $18,000 to $36,000 / week. Usually included: housekeeping, pool, grounds. Usually not: chef, daily staff.
Why it ranks here: Hudson is the river city of Warren Street antiques, galleries, and restaurants, with country houses on the farms around it and the Olana estate of the painter Frederic Church across the river, the pocket for a group that wants the design-and-antiques scene with a country base. A five-bedroom here is the pick for the Hudson scene and the Columbia farms.
What we would change: Hudson the city is small and busy on weekends, so the better houses sit on the farms a few miles out rather than in town. Book it for Warren Street and the galleries, with the country a short drive from the shops.
Get the free villa buyer’s guide
No. IV
The Woodstock and eastern Catskills villa, five-bedroom.
Typical: 5 BR, sleeps 10. Pocket: Woodstock and the Catskills foothills, Ulster. Peak rate: $16,000 to $34,000 / week. Usually included: housekeeping, pool or hot tub, grounds. Usually not: chef, the river on foot.
Why it ranks here: Woodstock is the arts town in the Catskills foothills below Overlook Mountain, the west-bank pocket of modern barns and mountain houses with trails, galleries, and the music history, the pick for a group that wants the mountains and the arts over the river estates. A five-bedroom here is the pick for the Catskills side of the valley.
What we would change: Woodstock is in the foothills, so the houses are mountain and forest rather than river, and the Hudson is a 20-minute drive east. Book it for the trails, the arts, and the woods, with the river towns a short run away.
Get the free villa buyer’s guide
No. V
The Cold Spring and Garrison river villa, five-bedroom.
Typical: 5 BR, sleeps 10. Pocket: Cold Spring and Garrison, Putnam. Peak rate: $16,000 to $34,000 / week. Usually included: housekeeping, pool, grounds. Usually not: chef, big acreage.
Why it ranks here: Cold Spring and Garrison are the river towns closest to New York City, about an hour north, with the Hudson Highlands rising across the water, the Boscobel house, and the Metro-North line, the pocket for a group that wants the river drama and the short trip from the city. A five-bedroom here is the pick for the closest, most scenic stretch of river.
What we would change: the Highlands are steep and the plots smaller than the northern estates, so you trade acreage for the river view and the proximity. Book it for the view and the easy trip, accepting less land than Millbrook or Rhinebeck.
Get the free villa buyer’s guide
No. VI
The Tivoli, Red Hook, and Germantown villa, five-bedroom.
Typical: 5 BR, sleeps 10. Pocket: the northern Dutchess river belt. Peak rate: $16,000 to $32,000 / week. Usually included: housekeeping, pool, grounds. Usually not: chef, a big village.
Why it ranks here: the villages of Tivoli, Red Hook, and Germantown sit just north of Rhinebeck near Bard College and the river, a quieter pocket of farmhouses and small estates with the same restaurants and farms close by, the pick for a group that wants the Rhinebeck country at a slightly lower number. A five-bedroom here is the value pick for the northern east bank.
What we would change: the villages are small and sleepy, so the dining and shopping concentrate in Rhinebeck and Hudson a short drive away. Book it for the quiet and the farms, with the bigger towns a few minutes off.
Get the free villa buyer’s guide
No. VII
The New Paltz and Gardiner villa, five-bedroom.
Typical: 5 BR, sleeps 10. Pocket: New Paltz and Gardiner, the Shawangunks, Ulster. Peak rate: $15,000 to $30,000 / week. Usually included: housekeeping, pool or hot tub, grounds. Usually not: chef, the river near.
Why it ranks here: New Paltz and Gardiner sit below the Shawangunk ridge near the Mohonk Mountain House and the Minnewaska park, a pocket of farms and modern houses with the best climbing, hiking, and ridge views in the valley, the pick for a group that wants the outdoors and the ridge. A five-bedroom here is the pick for the Shawangunks and the trails.
What we would change: the Gunks are southwest of the river, so this pocket is about the ridge and the parks rather than the Hudson, which is a 20-minute drive. Book it for the climbing, the hiking, and the views, with the river towns a short run east.
Get the free villa buyer’s guide
No. VIII
The Catskills high-peaks villa, five-bedroom.
Typical: 5 BR, sleeps 10. Pocket: Phoenicia, Mount Tremper, and the high peaks, Ulster. Peak rate: $15,000 to $30,000 / week. Usually included: housekeeping, hot tub, grounds. Usually not: chef, the river, a village on foot.
Why it ranks here: the high Catskills around Phoenicia and Mount Tremper hold mountain houses on the creeks below the peaks, with the deepest woods, the best skiing at Belleayre and Hunter in winter, and the coolest summer air, the pocket for a group that wants the mountains over the river. A five-bedroom here is the pick for the high peaks and the four-season trails.
What we would change: the high peaks are a 30 to 40-minute drive from the river towns, so this is a mountain base rather than a valley one. Book it for the woods, the creeks, and the skiing, accepting the distance from the Hudson.
Get the free villa buyer’s guide
No. IX
The Kingston and Rondout villa, four-bedroom.
Typical: 4 BR, sleeps 8. Pocket: Kingston and the Rondout, Ulster. Peak rate: $14,000 to $28,000 / week. Usually included: housekeeping, pool where present, parking. Usually not: chef, big grounds.
Why it ranks here: Kingston is the restored old city on the west bank, with the stockade district, the Rondout waterfront, restaurants, and a growing design scene, the pocket for a group that wants a walkable town base with the Catskills and the river both close. A four-bedroom townhouse or nearby farmhouse here is the pick for the city version on the west bank.
What we would change: Kingston is a working city rather than a village, so the appeal is the restaurants and the waterfront more than the countryside, which starts a few minutes out. Book it for the town life and the central position, with the woods and the river both a short drive.
Get the free villa buyer’s guide
No. X
The Stone Ridge and High Falls villa, five-bedroom.
Typical: 5 BR, sleeps 10. Pocket: Stone Ridge and High Falls, Ulster. Peak rate: $14,000 to $28,000 / week. Usually included: housekeeping, pool, grounds. Usually not: chef, a big village.
Why it ranks here: Stone Ridge and High Falls are the stone-house hamlets between Kingston and New Paltz, old Dutch farmhouses and barns on the Rondout creek, a quiet pocket of restored houses and farm restaurants, the pick for a group that wants the historic stone-house country. A five-bedroom here is the pick for the old Dutch farm setting.
What we would change: the hamlets are small and rural, so the dining is a handful of good farm spots and the towns are a short drive. Book it for the stone houses and the creek, with Kingston and New Paltz a few minutes off.
Get the free villa buyer’s guide
No. XI
The Beacon and southern gateway villa, four-bedroom.
Typical: 4 BR, sleeps 8. Pocket: Beacon and the southern gateway, Dutchess. Peak rate: $14,000 to $26,000 / week. Usually included: housekeeping, pool where present, parking. Usually not: chef, big acreage.
Why it ranks here: Beacon is the gateway town at the southern end of the valley, home to the Dia art museum, a long main street of shops, and the Metro-North line about 80 minutes from the city, the pocket for a group that wants the shortest trip, the art, and a walkable base. A four-bedroom here is the pick for the southern gateway and the easiest arrival.
What we would change: Beacon sits at the busy southern end near the highway, so the setting is town and gateway rather than deep country, which is north. Book it for Dia, the main street, and the short trip, with the country an hour north.
Get the free villa buyer’s guide
No. XII
The Stanfordville and Dutchess back-roads villa, five-bedroom.
Typical: 5 BR, sleeps 10. Pocket: Stanfordville and the inland Dutchess back roads. Peak rate: $14,000 to $24,000 / week. Usually included: housekeeping, pool, grounds. Usually not: chef, a village on foot, the river near.
Why it ranks here: the back roads inland of Rhinebeck and Millbrook around Stanfordville, Pine Plains, and Clinton Corners hold farmhouses on acreage at the lowest rates in the valley, the most land per dollar away from the river and the named villages, the contrarian pick for a group that wants room and a pool at a country price. A five-bedroom here is the lowest-number pick for acreage.
What we would change: these are deep-country plots, so the river and the named towns are a 15 to 25-minute drive and the setting is farmland rather than estate. Book it for the space, the pool, and the value, with the villages a short run away.
Get the free villa buyer’s guide