Section I · The Ranked Twelve
From best to twelfth.
Sorted by what each pocket does well at its price point. The number-one pick is the one we would book first given a free pick from all twelve.
No. I
The Oil Nut Bay ridge-and-beach estate, six-bedroom.
Typical: 6 BR, sleeps 12. Pocket: Oil Nut Bay, North Sound. Peak rate: $90,000 to $200,000 / week. Usually included: full staff, chef or kitchen team, housekeeping, the resort amenities and beach club. Usually not: boat charter, off-property excursions.
Why it ranks here: Oil Nut Bay, the gated community at the eastern tip reached only by boat or helicopter, is the trophy address of the BVI, a collection of architect-built estates with beach-club, marina, and dining amenities and the most complete service on the island. A ridge-and-beach villa here is the most private and the most fully staffed week Virgin Gorda offers, and the North Sound sailing on the doorstep is the finest in the Caribbean.
What we would change: the boat-only access is the whole point and also the catch. Every grocery run, every off-property dinner, and every guest arrival is a boat trip, so the week works best for a group happy to stay inside the community. For more flexibility, drop to Nail Bay at No. III.
Get the free villa buyer’s guide
No. II
The Mahoe Bay beachfront villa, five-bedroom.
Typical: 5 BR, sleeps 10. Pocket: Mahoe Bay. Peak rate: $42,000 to $90,000 / week. Usually included: housekeeping, pool maintenance. Usually not: chef, daily housekeeping, driver.
Why it ranks here: Mahoe Bay, on the calm north-west coast, has the best swimmable beachfront on the road-accessible part of the island, a long crescent of pale sand and shallow water. A five-bedroom directly on the sand here gives a group true beachfront with a car and a road, which the boat-only North Sound estates trade away. It is the best balance of beach, privacy, and access on Virgin Gorda.
What we would change: the genuine beachfront villas at Mahoe are few and book a year out for the Christmas window. Confirm the villa is on the sand and not across the road, because the gap between true beachfront and a sea-view villa over the road is large here.
Get the free villa buyer’s guide
No. III
The Nail Bay hillside sea-view estate, six-bedroom.
Typical: 6 BR, sleeps 12. Pocket: Nail Bay. Peak rate: $38,000 to $84,000 / week. Usually included: housekeeping, pool and garden maintenance. Usually not: chef, driver.
Why it ranks here: Nail Bay, the north-west resort area, holds the largest concentration of substantial sea-view estates with road access, terraced on the hill above three beaches with long views toward Tortola and the outer islands. A six-bedroom here is the pick for a larger group that wants space, a serious pool, a sunset outlook, and the freedom of a car, at a rate below the beachfront and the North Sound.
What we would change: the hillside villas mean a short drive or a steep path down to the beaches rather than stepping onto the sand. Right for a group that lives around the pool and the view; less so for one that wants the beach at the door.
Get the free villa buyer’s guide
No. IV
The North Sound / Leverick Bay water-access villa, five-bedroom.
Typical: 5 BR, sleeps 10. Pocket: Leverick Bay / North Sound. Peak rate: $40,000 to $88,000 / week. Usually included: housekeeping, dock or mooring access. Usually not: chef, the boat itself.
Why it ranks here: The North Sound around Leverick Bay is the sailing heart of the BVI, with a dock or a mooring at the villa and the Bitter End, Saba Rock, and the outer reefs minutes away by tender. A five-bedroom with water access here is the pick for a group built around the boat, where the day starts at the dock and the North Sound is the front garden.
What we would change: the value here is entirely the water, so a villa without its own dock or easy tender access loses most of the point. Confirm the mooring and the tender arrangement in writing before booking on the sailing premise.
Get the free villa buyer’s guide
No. V
The Mango Bay beachfront cottage cluster, four-bedroom.
Typical: 4 BR, sleeps 8. Pocket: Mango Bay. Peak rate: $34,000 to $70,000 / week. Usually included: housekeeping, beach access. Usually not: chef, single-building layout.
Why it ranks here: Mango Bay, next to Mahoe on the north-west coast, holds beachfront villas and cottage clusters on a quiet stretch of sand with shallow, child-safe water. A four-bedroom here is the pick for a smaller family that wants the beach at the door without the price of the trophy estates, and the calm bay is among the easiest swimming on the island.
What we would change: some of the beachfront properties here are cottage clusters rather than a single villa, which suits some groups and not others. Confirm whether the bedrooms are under one roof or spread across cottages before booking for a group that wants to be together.
Get the free villa buyer’s guide
No. VI
The Little Dix / St Thomas Bay villa, five-bedroom.
Typical: 5 BR, sleeps 10. Pocket: Little Dix Bay / St Thomas Bay. Peak rate: $36,000 to $76,000 / week. Usually included: housekeeping, pool maintenance, near the resort and the marina. Usually not: chef, driver.
Why it ranks here: The St Thomas Bay area near the Rosewood Little Dix Bay resort and the Spanish Town marina is the most connected villa pocket, walkable or a short drive to the ferry, the shops, the resort dining, and The Baths. A five-bedroom here suits a group that wants the island’s amenities close and an easy arrival, without the boat-only isolation of the North Sound.
What we would change: this is the busiest, most built-up corner of a very quiet island, so it trades some seclusion for convenience. Right for a first visit or a group that wants the marina and the resort nearby; less so for one seeking total privacy.
Get the free villa buyer’s guide
No. VII
The Savannah Bay / Pond Bay sea-view villa, five-bedroom.
Typical: 5 BR, sleeps 10. Pocket: Savannah Bay / Pond Bay. Peak rate: $28,000 to $62,000 / week. Usually included: housekeeping, pool maintenance. Usually not: chef, driver.
Why it ranks here: Savannah Bay is the long, empty, postcard beach on the central north coast, and the sea-view villas on the hill above it look down a mile of pale sand with almost no one on it. A five-bedroom here is the value pick for the best beach view on the island, the lowest entry rate on this list, and a short drive to The Baths and the marina.
What we would change: the villas sit above the beach rather than on it, so reaching the sand is a short drive or walk. The trade is the lowest rate and arguably the finest beach outlook on Virgin Gorda.
Get the free villa buyer’s guide
No. VIII
The Valley / Spanish Town near-Baths villa, four-bedroom.
Typical: 4 BR, sleeps 8. Pocket: The Valley / Spanish Town. Peak rate: $30,000 to $60,000 / week. Usually included: housekeeping, pool maintenance, near The Baths. Usually not: chef, driver.
Why it ranks here: The Valley, the south end around Spanish Town, puts a group within minutes of The Baths, the granite-boulder swimming grottoes that are the island’s signature, and the shops and ferry. A four-bedroom here is the smaller-group pick for easy access to the famous sight, the marina, and a more local, lived-in side of the island.
What we would change: The Baths draw day-trippers from the cruise tenders and the charter boats, so the south end is the busiest part of the island by day. Visit The Baths early or late, and use the villa for the quiet of the evening when the day boats have gone.
Get the free villa buyer’s guide
No. IX
The Plum Bay / south-coast cliff villa, four-bedroom.
Typical: 4 BR, sleeps 8. Pocket: Plum Bay / south coast. Peak rate: $30,000 to $64,000 / week. Usually included: housekeeping, pool maintenance. Usually not: chef, easy beach access.
Why it ranks here: The south-coast cliffs near Plum Bay and the approach to The Baths hold dramatic villas perched over the water with the boulder coastline below and long views toward the outer islands. A four-bedroom here gives a smaller group privacy, a striking outlook, and proximity to The Baths and Devil’s Bay, two of the best swimming spots on the island.
What we would change: the clifftop position means a path or a drive to a beach rather than direct sand access. Book it for the drama and the swimming grottoes nearby, not for a step-out-to-the-beach week.
Get the free villa buyer’s guide
No. X
The Pond Bay hillside value villa, four-bedroom.
Typical: 4 BR, sleeps 8. Pocket: Pond Bay. Peak rate: $28,000 to $56,000 / week. Usually included: housekeeping, pool maintenance. Usually not: chef, driver, beachfront.
Why it ranks here: Pond Bay, on the central north coast near Savannah Bay, holds smaller sea-view villas at the value end of the market, a short drive from the best central beaches and the marina. A four-bedroom here is the contrarian pick for a group that wants the central position and the beach proximity at the lowest rates on the island.
What we would change: these are the more modest villas on the list, sea-view rather than trophy, so set expectations on scale. Book it for the location and the price, knowing the house is the base rather than the spectacle.
Get the free villa buyer’s guide
No. XI
The Handsome Bay / east-coast quiet villa, four-bedroom.
Typical: 4 BR, sleeps 8. Pocket: Handsome Bay / east coast. Peak rate: $28,000 to $54,000 / week. Usually included: housekeeping, pool maintenance. Usually not: chef, lively surroundings.
Why it ranks here: The east coast around Handsome Bay is the quietest, least developed road-accessible part of the island, with sea-view villas looking out toward the Atlantic side and almost no traffic. A four-bedroom here is the pick for a group that wants real seclusion without the boat-only commitment of the North Sound, at a value rate.
What we would change: the east coast is genuinely quiet, which means a longer drive to the marina, The Baths, and the best swimming beaches. Right for a group that wants to retreat; less so for one that wants the island’s sights close.
Get the free villa buyer’s guide
No. XII
The Valley interior near-town villa, three-bedroom.
Typical: 3 BR, sleeps 6. Pocket: The Valley interior. Peak rate: $28,000 to $48,000 / week. Usually included: housekeeping, pool maintenance. Usually not: chef, sea frontage, trophy view.
Why it ranks here: The interior of the Valley near Spanish Town holds smaller three-bedroom villas walkable or a short drive from the marina, the shops, and the ferry, the practical pick for a couple or a small family that wants the island without a large house. It is the most convenient and the most attainable entry on the list.
What we would change: the interior villas lack the sea view and the beachfront that define the rest of the list, so they are about access and price rather than outlook. Book it for the convenience and the lower rate, with the beaches a short drive away.
Get the free villa buyer’s guide